Spray Foam & Rigid Foam Insulation Comparison

Best-suited for big jobs. Two-part spray foam provides excellent air sealing and insulation, and is often sprayed against open framing, as in this attic installation.

Traditionally, fiberglass batt insulation has been the go to method of insulating attics, walls, and more. However, today's homeowners, contractors and building scientists (the experts who study home energy performance) spend a lot of time talking about foam insulation.

This newly popular insulation can come in many forms. Right now, let's consider the differences between the spray foam and rigid foam. More specifically, we can compare the closed-cell spray foam that requires two components to be mixed at the application nozzle, and the rigid foam insulation boards that come in different thicknesses.

Both two-component spray foam and rigid foam are useful for improving home energy performance. Sometimes it can be difficult to decide whether spray foam or rigid foam is best for a particular application.

Find out which insulation is right for your home

Insulation is essential for energy efficiency, and nobody knows insulation better than County Comfort Home Solutions. Call or email today to arrange for a free estimate for home insulation in Cortlandt, Mount Pleasant, Yorktown, Ossining, Carmel, Peekskill, Yonkers, Cortlandt Manor, Yorktown Heights, Verplanck, and nearby areas in New York.

The Pros and Cons of Spray Foam and Rigid Foam Insulation

Two-Component Spray Foam

Pros:	Provides both insulation and air sealing; air sealing is excellent because the foam expands to fill gaps and cracks. High R-value —about R-7 per in. depending on formulation. Speedy installation. Foaming can be done in a fraction of the time it takes to cut, fit, and seal rigid board insulation. Once cured, spray foam insulation stays in place; it won't shift, settle, or fall out of place.
Cons:	Messy; overspray can deposit foam where it must be removed. Respirators and protective clothing must be worn during installation. If the area being insulated cannot be isolated from living space, occupants must vacate premises until foam cures – typically two hours. Temperature sensitive; cold temperatures can cause problems with foaming action or curing. R-value can degrade slightly over time.

Rigid Foam insulation

Pros:	Provides both insulation and air sealing, provided that seams between foam panels are sealed with tape. Less messy than spray foam. Different thicknesses are available to suit different application & R-value requirements. Panels are easy to cut and can be installed in any temperature. Safe handling; no harmful emissions during installation. Best installation for insulating crawl space and basement walls. Some rigid foam panels (like SilverGlo™, for example) include a radiant barrier for additional energy savings.
Cons:	R-value varies based on type of rigid foam. It can be as low as R-3.8 per in. or as high as R-8 per in. More time-consuming installation than spray foam in some (but not all) applications. Sometimes single-component spray foam must be applied around edges of rigid foam to seal and hold panel in place.

Be sure to check out our other content to help in choosing the best spray foam insulation and the best spray foam contractor in New York.

Looking for a price? Get a no cost, no obligation free estimate.